[Tango-L] Dancing socially to Piazzolla
Myk Dowling
politas at gmail.com
Mon Jul 21 11:57:32 EDT 2008
melvillefox at aol.com wrote:
>
> Dancing to Piazzolla (never danced to socially in Buenos Aires) does
> not make it tango. Piazzolla himself said he did not compose music for
> dancing.
I'm always amused when people make definitive statements on mailing
lists. They are nearly invariably incorrect. Especially in cases like
this. All we need is one person to report a Piazzolla track played for
social dancing in Buenos Aires just the once, and the statement is made
absurd.
Given the number of Piazzolla pieces being re-used by other tango bands,
it seems rather unlikely to me that Piazzolla is "never danced to
socially in Buenos Aires".
Unless perhaps, Mel thinks that Nuevo Tango (You know, that type of
music that Piazzolla created) isn't "social dancing", which would be
taking the common dismissive attitude to Nuevo shown around here to
extremes.
When exactly did Piazzolla say that he "did not compose music for
dancing"? I'd love to see the actual quote, particularly in context.
--
Myk Dowling
More information about the Tango-L
mailing list