[LCM Articles] Lebanon's meaning in the wider Arab context

[Loai Naamani]

Lebanon's meaning in the wider Arab context

by Rami G. Khouri | Advisory Release: 15 March 2005

 

 

Something very important to the Arab world continues to take place on the streets of Beirut, and it is not primarily about being
pro- or anti-Syrian. Neither is it mainly about political anthropology -- the counting of headscarves, bellybutton rings, beards and
designer shoes among the street demonstrators, in order to note their ethnic, religious and ideological identity.

 

Having attended all the demonstrations, I am convinced that Lebanon these days represents a historic, unprecedented, drive for
national self-determination by Arab citizens. The Lebanese seek to define three crucial aspects of their national identity and power
structure that no Arab citizenry has ever done in the past eight decades or so of nominal Arab independence: a) the nature of their
sovereignty and political configuration; b) the nature of their relations with neighboring states and foreign powers; and, c) the
relationship among their own military/security sector, the average citizen, and the institutions of governance.

 

The Arab people for the most part have never enjoyed the opportunity to define their most basic attributes of sovereignty and
statehood. In several ridiculous cases last century, retreating European colonial powers defined the concepts, drew the borders, and
hand picked the rulers of novel Arab countries that were formed primarily to serve European colonial interests.

 

This is history, for sure, but one whose enduring impact still drives events in tortured Arab lands today. This is partly because
major Western powers that now champion Arab freedom and democracy for half a century installed, anchored, armed and assuaged the
stubborn autocrats whose long reigns have made the Arab world the globe's last non-democratic region. More and more Arabs now
explicitly challenge the economic, security and political control mechanisms of this flawed modern order. Lebanon is the first
serious example of spontaneous, indigenous Arab political activism to challenge and replace the ugly power structures that have
plagued this region for nearly a century.

 

The particulars of the Lebanon case also reflect the core elements of national self-determination that apply to all other Arab
countries. The key issues in Lebanon are:

 

*	the nature, legitimacy and durability of the governing security- and Syrian-associated elite headed by President Emile
Lahoud, which is increasingly widely challenged and politically weakened;

 

*	how the popular Hezbollah party can move from its heroic genesis of liberating the south from Israeli occupation to an
expected new future political role, given its status as Lebanon's single most formidable political party;

 

*	whether the emerging powerful coalition of opposition forces can channel its massive popular appeal into an effective
political strategy that goes beyond the anger at Rafik Hariri's murder and the successful push to secure a Syrian military
withdrawal from Lebanon;

 

*	whether an opposition-Hezbollah national alliance representing the vast majority of Lebanese can quickly agree on the next
steps to form a credible government, hold clean parliamentary elections, redefine good neighborly, close Syrian-Lebanese relations,
bring the security-military systems under civilian control, and launch urgently needed economic and political reforms; and

 

*	how a self-determinant, reconfigured, democratic Lebanon can define mutually beneficial relations with non-Arab powers like
Iran, Israel, the U.S. and others.

 

These Lebanese issues mirror broad political principles and individual human aspirations that are common throughout the Arab world,
where citizens more openly challenge numerous old, stubborn, security-focused, externally-designed, tattered and discredited Arab
governance systems. The new governance systems that Arab citizens design will be determined by the consensus that emerges from the
political negotiations that have been initiated by the street demonstrations by the principal groupings.

 

Securing a Syrian pledge to leave Lebanon proved to be rather easy, in retrospect, given the Lebanese, Arab and international
consensus on this.

 

The more difficult task now underway requires a new social and political compact among the Lebanese people to establish a better,
more accountable governance system that ensures citizens individual and collective rights, and accommodates their varied
ideological, ethnic, religious and social values.

 

Lebanon's dueling demonstrations are not really very confrontational, and in fact are rather compatible in their core demands. There
is acknowledgement and consensus on the facts that: Syria is leaving Lebanon, the Hariri murder must be investigated fully and those
responsible brought to justice, a clean parliamentary election in May must accurately reflect the real balance of political forces
in the country, Hezbollah must maintain its current armed resistance and political party status until Israel signs peace treaties
with all neighboring Arab states, and, a new government in Lebanon must affirm the equal rights of citizens more than the security
of a privileged, non-accountable, and often imposed elite.

 

These enormous challenges reflect the epic valor and complexity of national self-determination for any country or people, as Lebanon
contemplates the potential reconfiguration of its entire national power structure. Half a century ago, Lebanon briefly and
incompletely offered the Arab world an intriguing model of parliamentary democracy that soon was swamped and disfigured by the
combined weight of the cold war, the Arab-Israeli conflict, its own civil war, and the stultifying modern Arab security state.
Today, Lebanon may again lead the way for other Arabs who covet the same personal and national goals of normal statehood, a decent
and accountable government, and reasonably equal opportunities for all its citizens.

 

Rami G. Khouri is editor-at-large of the Beirut-based Daily Star newspaper,
published throughout the Middle East with the International Herald Tribune.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mailman.mit.edu/pipermail/lebanon-articles/attachments/20050316/c0e6221c/attachment.htm