[LCM Articles] Rice Alarms Reformist Arabs with Stability Remarks

Tue Mar 29 19:35:40 EST 2005

Rice Alarms Reformist Arabs with Stability Remarks

Tue Mar 29, 7:36 AM ET

<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/addtomy/*http://add.my.yahoo.com/content?i
d=6400&.src=yn&.done=http%3a//news.yahoo.com/news%3ftmpl=story%26u=/nm/20050
329/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc> Add to My Yahoo!
<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/addtomy/*http://add.my.yahoo.com/content?i
d=6400&.src=yn&.done=http%3a//news.yahoo.com/news%3ftmpl=story%26u=/nm/20050
329/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc> Politics - Reuters	

By Jonathan Wright 

CAIRO (Reuters) - Secretary of State Condoleezza
<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/DailyNews/manual/nm/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc/14711
339/*http://news.search.yahoo.com/search/news?fr=news-storylinks&p=%22Condol
eezza%20Rice%22&c=&n=20&yn=c&c=news&cs=nw> Rice has alarmed many reformist
Arabs with comments suggesting a new U.S. approach that promotes rapid
political change without regard for internal stability. 

<http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/050329/photos_pl_afp/0503291
82422_mpjykoqi_photo0> Photo

<http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/050329/photos_pl_afp/0503291
82422_mpjykoqi_photo0> AFP/File Photo 

Rice said in an interview with the Washington Post last week the Middle East
status quo was not stable and she doubted it would be stable soon.
Washington would speak out for "freedom" without offering a model or knowing
what the outcome would be. 

"This a very dangerous scheme. Anarchy will be out of control," said Hassan
Nafaa, a professor of political science at Cairo University and an advocate
of gradual change. 

A liberal Arab diplomat, who asked not to be named, said: "They seem to be
supporting chaos and instability as a pretext for bringing democracy. But
people would rather live under undemocratic rule than in the chaotic
atmosphere of Iraq
<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/DailyNews/manual/nm/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc/14711
339/*http://news.search.yahoo.com/search/news?fr=news-storylinks&p=%22Iraq%2
2&c=&n=20&yn=c&c=news&cs=nw> , for example, which the Americans tout as a
model." 

U.S. policy in the Middle East has traditionally given priority to the
stability of cooperative governments such as those in Egypt, Jordan and
Saudi Arabia, while turning a blind eye to the way those governments treat
their peoples. 

Mohamed el-Sayed Said, a liberal who has challenged Egyptian President Hosni
<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/DailyNews/manual/nm/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc/14711
339/*http://news.search.yahoo.com/search/news?fr=news-storylinks&p=%22Hosni%
20Mubarak%22&c=&n=20&yn=c&c=news&cs=nw> Mubarak to his face over
authoritarian government, said Arab societies were too fragile for the kind
of rapid and unchecked change that Rice appears to welcome. 

Apart from the danger of extremists coming to power, the Arab world would
face the threat that societies and states could collapse completely, he told
Reuters. 

"We can hardly take the great risks that Dr Rice suggests. We are determined
to keep domestic peace as well as external peace as far as we can, but not
to the point of stifling change," added Said, who is deputy director of the
al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies in Cairo. 

"TOTALLY CAVALIER ATTITUDE" 

The Bush administration has argued that political violence and hostility to
the United States in the Middle East are the result of internal repression,
rather than of U.S. policies in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the main
Arab grievance. 

That argument is at the core of President
<http://us.rd.yahoo.com/DailyNews/manual/nm/pl_nm/mideast_stability_dc/14711
339/*http://news.search.yahoo.com/search/news?fr=news-storylinks&p=%22Presid
ent%20Bush%22&c=&n=20&yn=c&c=news&cs=nw> Bush's campaign for domestic
political change in Arab countries, which has had a mixed reception even
among Arab liberals. 

His campaign has stimulated the debate on reform in the Middle East and
emboldened some democrats to challenge governments which now appear to be on
the defensive. 

Rice's remarks went one step further, suggesting the United States was
willing to take a gamble on "democratic institutions" having a "moderating
influence" in the region. 

"Can we be certain of that? No. But do I think there's a strong certainty
that the Middle East was not going to stay stable anyway? Yes. And when you
know that the status quo is no longer defensible, then you have to be
willing to move in another direction," she said. 

Helena Cobban, a writer on Middle East affairs based in the United States,
said: "She (Rice) reveals a totally cavalier attitude to the whole
non-trivial concept of social-political stability in Middle Eastern
countries." 

"So it looks as though Arc of Instability may now actually be the goal of
U.S. policy, rather than its diagnosis of an existing problem," she added. 

Mohamed el-Sayed Said said Rice's approach appeared to have links with a
trend in right-wing Israeli thinking that favors destabilising Arab
governments and societies. 

"We see an emphasis on destruction and we see that Israel is willing to push
Arab societies to the abyss without caring for stability. We suspect these
ideas came from Israel," he added. 

"COMPREHENSIVE REFORM" 

Hala Mustafa, editor of the Egyptian quarterly publication Democracy Review,
said reformers must have a clear agenda for where they want to go and that
instant change would favor the Islamists, who dominate the political
culture. 

"If we start without any agenda, it will end in confusion ... We are talking
about comprehensive reform that would lead to the change we need, not to
turmoil or chaos," she added. 

Rice, asked about the prospect of Islamist victories through reform, said
that would not be desirable. 

But she added: "It is really as opposed to what at this point? It isn't as
if the status quo was stable the way that it was ... The only thing the
United States can do is to speak out for the values that have been absent,
liberty and freedom there, and it will have to take its own course." 

Abdel Raouf El Reedy, a former Egyptian ambassador to the United States and
chairman of the Egyptian Council for Foreign Relations, said the United
States was overlooking its own responsibility to settle the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict. 

"If the United States wants to be credible, it has to be serious about
ending the military occupation (of Palestinian territories) because this is
generating resentment and anger and in this way helping the radical forces
in the region," he said. 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mailman.mit.edu/pipermail/lebanon-articles/attachments/20050329/6ca8f8b3/attachment.htm
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: image/gif
Size: 568 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman.mit.edu/pipermail/lebanon-articles/attachments/20050329/6ca8f8b3/attachment.gif
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 4347 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman.mit.edu/pipermail/lebanon-articles/attachments/20050329/6ca8f8b3/attachment.jpg